Use authoritative reference data where reproducible data is available.
OUR METHODOLOGY
How insurance estimates work
InsureSmarts provides a planning estimate to help you understand how broad insurance factors can affect cost. It is not an offer, bindable quote, or coverage recommendation.
Label simplified factors as planning assumptions, not insurer formulas.
Results show planning sensitivity rather than guaranteed premiums.
Explain what the estimator does not know or retrieve.
STARTING POINT
How the auto estimate begins
The auto estimator begins with a nationwide planning baseline and uses the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) 2024 combined average personal-auto premium data to create a relative state index. Each state is compared with the 2024 countrywide combined average premium of $1,612.81. The estimator then applies simplified vehicle, coverage, and driver adjustments. Those additional adjustments are educational modeling assumptions, not insurer rating formulas.
View the NAIC 2024 Auto Insurance Database Average Premium Supplement →
OTHER ESTIMATORS
Different insurance categories use different starting points
Homeowners and renters use 2026 Insurance.com/Quadrant state sample-rate baselines. The homeowners sample represents a $300,000 dwelling, $300,000 liability limit, $1,000 base deductible, and a 2% hurricane deductible where applicable. The renters sample represents $40,000 of personal property, $100,000 liability, a $1,000 deductible, and good credit. These are published sample-rate benchmarks, not in-force national averages or insurer quotes. Flood uses an $82-per-month national planning benchmark derived from July 2026 NFIP new-or-renewed policy transactions, plus FEMA Risk Rating 2.0 concepts such as foundation and first-floor height, with building and contents coverage modeled separately. The FEMA-derived $82 figure is not an in-force national average and is not an individual property quote. The estimator does not reproduce FEMA's full property-level rating engine. Motorcycle, RV, boat, condo, landlord, umbrella, pet, life, dental, and vision use simplified planning models rather than live carrier rate filings or bindable quote data. The life model also uses broad age, coverage, term, tobacco-use, and health-profile assumptions; these are not carrier underwriting classes or medical underwriting decisions.
Travel insurance is modeled as a per-trip premium rather than a monthly premium. The current planning baseline uses 2026 Squaremouth marketplace data tying comprehensive travel premiums to insured trip cost. Disability insurance is modeled as a share of annual income using a current 1%–3% income-cost benchmark and adjusted for age, occupation risk, benefit period, and elimination period. Long-term care uses a simplified 2026 market baseline informed by the American Association for Long-Term Care Insurance price index and then adjusts for purchase age, benefit pool, inflation option, and elimination period. The exact adjustment factors are InsureSmarts planning assumptions, not carrier rate formulas.
Dental and vision currently use clearly identified national planning assumptions rather than a claimed national average. HealthCare.gov publishes current stand-alone dental plan datasets, while adult stand-alone vision coverage is sold outside the federal Marketplace. These tools should be used to compare broad scenarios rather than predict an exact premium.
STATE ADJUSTMENTS
How state adjustments work
For personal-auto estimates and the Cheapest Cars to Insure comparison, all 50 states plus the District of Columbia use a relative index derived from NAIC 2024 combined average premiums. NAIC cautions that state averages are not directly comparable as equal insurance products because coverage choices, laws, vehicle mix, demographics, and other conditions differ.
Other insurance types do not automatically reuse the auto index. Where InsureSmarts does not yet have an appropriate category-specific state dataset, the result either uses the national planning baseline or clearly identifies a simplified model assumption rather than presenting it as sourced state pricing.
Insurance by State pages use these same published datasets for broad comparison: the 2024 NAIC auto index plus the NAIC-sourced 2022 HO-3 homeowners and HO-4 renters state averages. They do not add unsourced state legal requirements or pretend a statewide average is a local quote.
SOURCE MATRIX
Where published data enters the estimator
This table shows the current role of published data in the estimator. A published baseline does not mean every adjustment in that estimator comes from the same source.
| Insurance category | Published reference | How InsureSmarts uses it |
|---|---|---|
| Personal auto | NAIC 2024 Auto Insurance Database Average Premium Supplement | State relative premium index. Vehicle, driver, coverage, deductible, mileage, and ZIP-area adjustments are planning assumptions. |
| Homeowners | 2026 Insurance.com/Quadrant state sample rates | State sample-rate starting point. Replacement cost, property type, construction year, deductible, and roof-age adjustments are planning assumptions. |
| Renters | 2026 Insurance.com/Quadrant state sample rates | State sample-rate starting point. Coverage, deductible, and residence-type adjustments are planning assumptions. |
| Flood | FEMA Risk Rating 2.0 concepts | Used for risk-factor concepts such as foundation and first-floor height. The $82 monthly benchmark is derived from July 2026 NFIP new-or-renewed policy transactions. It is not an in-force national average or an individual property quote; the simplified multipliers are InsureSmarts assumptions. |
| Travel | 2026 Squaremouth marketplace cost data | Comprehensive trip-cost benchmark. Age and coverage-level adjustments are simplified planning assumptions. |
| Disability | Current 1%–3% of income cost benchmark | Uses a 2% planning midpoint, then applies age, occupation, benefit-period, and elimination-period assumptions. |
| Long-term care | AALTCI 2026 Long-Term Care Insurance Price Index | Informs the baseline, with purchase age, benefit pool, inflation, and elimination-period adjustments modeled by InsureSmarts. |
| Dental & vision | HealthCare.gov plan and coverage information | Used for current plan context. Dollar starting points remain national planning assumptions. |
| Motorcycle, RV, boat, condo, landlord, umbrella, pet & life | No single verified public rate table currently used | These tools use clearly identified national planning baselines and simplified assumptions until stronger reproducible datasets are available. |
ESTIMATE RANGE
Why you see a range
Two people with similar cars can receive very different real-world prices. Insurers may weigh territory, claims history, coverage limits, discounts, prior coverage, credit-based insurance information where permitted, and their own underwriting rules differently. The displayed range is a modeled sensitivity band around the planning estimate. It is not a statistical confidence interval, a distribution of actual customer premiums, or a set of live insurer quotes.
LIMITATIONS
What the estimate does not know
InsureSmarts does not pull a motor vehicle report, claims report, credit-based insurance score, VIN-level equipment data, insurer pricing files, or a live quote. When you enter a ZIP code in the advanced auto estimator, only a broad three-digit ZIP territory adjustment is used for the planning estimate. The full ZIP code is not sent to an insurer.
OUR NEXT STEP
Better calibration as stronger data becomes available
As the product develops, we will calibrate the model against cited state, regulatory, and insurer datasets. Any future quote handoff will require clear consent before information is sent to a third party.
